
Watching Maxi and Suarez demolish lesser teams made me feel like the sky was the limit. In my enthusiasm, I made the typical fan assumption that any new players coming in (Carroll–I don’t include Gerrard) are ADDITIVE. They are not.
Today (Spurs @ Anfield) proved that to me. Today reminded me of the problem we had with Torres. When you run the offense through one guy, everybody KNOWS what you’re doing. It’s easy to defense. Beyond that, every ball that you try to force in to the “main” guy, is an opportunity that Suarez or Maxi or Dirk, DOES NOT have anymore.
Today, I got annoyed early and often that what passes for a smart ball now, isn’t a slick through ball to put Maxi or Suarez into space, deep, but basically ANY aerial ball to the vicinity of Carroll~! This is a ticket to 7th place next year. This will not get it done in the Prem!
You can not throw prayer after aerial prayer towards Carroll, when he is 20-25 yards out, and expect anything good to consistently happen. Kenny needs to get on this.
It amazed me when this was happening under Rafa and then Hodgson, and neither seemed to mind that they had TWO different offenses! One without Torres, where everyone worked hard and supported one another and found weaknesses in defenses and exploited them as they arose! It was pure improv, and good attacking football HAS to be mostly improv.
The other offense was the stodgy one with Torres on the pitch–where everyone was afraid to play a ball to anyone BUT, the fully covered Torres, and if they couldn’t do anything useful with the ball and they were knackered and out of options, they flicked it in the air in his direction and that passed for “service”.
If you were wondering where the swashbuckling, fearless, ground penetration was vs Spurs at Anfield today–the stuff of hat tricks in the last few games; if you were wondering where THAT was, then Carroll’s presence is your answer. And yes, Spurs played very much better than the recent opponents, I understand that, but to me, it was Carroll as the contaminant to the great recipe that had been brewing.
At 35 million Lbs, Carroll isn’t going anywhere, and, if he’s fit, he’s in the first XI. But that has me worried. Kenny MUST understand and cultivate the THINKING that lead to the nice run of goals WITHOUT Carroll. He must completely understand why that happened and work to make his players understand why also. He must strive to ensure that NO PLAYER is bigger than the system. The system must include freedom for guys like Maxi and Suarez and Kuyt to improvise heavily ON THE GROUND and above all else, they must feel comfortable leaving Carroll totally OUT of certain plans–and that has to be ok.
Think of it–Carroll can be an expensive dummy (running, essentially, what they call a “clean out route” in the NFL), at times and take defenders with him while space is opened up for the smaller, faster men to do their mayhem on the ground! This will work, but it has to be ok with everyone. Everyone must be on board. It can NOT be what it was with Benayoun being afraid to penetrate defenses himself on the ground so long as Torres was on the field.
And the fullbacks and holding Mids need to STOP being satisfied with a long ball just basically hoofed up to the vicinity of Carroll~! We need to work the ball forward in the pass-and-move that Kenny so skillfully returned us to only recently.
My fear? That we were hitting the right note without the slow Carroll and the slower Gerrard, and that now we will get away from it because (a) we have to play the 35 million man AND service him to the exclusion of all else, and (b) we HAVE to play Gerrard in the first XI every week, because, well, because he’s Steven Gerrard, and who cares if he’s quite a bit slower than the thing that has worked great this year–which is swashbuckling, ground speed and penetration–ie: forcing defenses out of their comfort zone–making them bend and opening up space somewhere nearby the ball carrier.
I really don’t want to see Gerrard at all next season. I love the guy–he’s a legend to me, but I just honestly think he’s a net negative now at his age. There’s no shame in that. There IS shame, however, in letting your ego dictate that you hang on, even if it hurts your team: ask the Yankees with Jeter and Posada.
In summation:
I AM concerned about Carroll’s pace, but time will tell.
I am very concerned that Carroll’s introduction will take Liverpool out of a real winning formula that they were in recently.
Kenny, if you want to win the Prem next year, and I think you can, you have to solve this issue. This is 100% a coaching issue. Players have to feel comfortable with a system that may bypass the star, even over and over again! It’s up to you, Kenny to preserve what you had while working in the big man. I’m not saying that he isn’t good or that I don’t like a big man who can head the ball. He will be successful. What I’m saying is that if he’s serviced to the exclusion of all else, there will be many long, goal less stretches next year and you can’t have that and win the Prem, which I really believe they can do. A good offense is multi-faceted. If you mark one phase of it out of the game, another will do damage. Look at ManU’s goal scoring tallies the last 20 years. Look at the goal distribution when Liverpool are going well recently.
Winning the Prem next year is also going to hinge on the defense–they need at least one, and maybe two, world class, super Centerbacks, and I’m not talking about Glen Johnson, who has played much better than early on, but who I would sell for just about any decent price.
Guys I would sell if price was right?
Gerrard
Johnson
Lucas (but must be backfilled w/ a top holding mid–remember Alonso’s passing? Mascherano’s defense?)
Guys I never want to see again?
Ngog
Kyrgiakos
Guys who I hope they retain:
Maxi Rodriguez
Joe Cole
Jovanovic
***
Last point: I had noticed that the run of real bad anti-Liverpool calls seemed to have ended when Kenny came in. I reasoned that Kenny, being a nice guy that everyone in UK footy admired greatly, had an effect on the refs. They seemed to call games more fairly. Today was the first day that I thought we were back to the old reffing. The PK on Flanagan was ridiculous. It wasn’t in the box. It wasn’t a goal scoring opportunity. It WAS a 50-50 shoulder challenge that the forward went down on to great effect. Suarez was getting knocked around pretty harshly as well, and he couldn’t get a call, although I wish he’d stop looking for it. Just get up and get on with it. When you work the ref, you undercut your case.
Anyway, I’ve been meaning to mention that the reffing has gotten less anti-Liverpool with Kenny and now just as I was getting used to it, this game reminded me of how it’s been for the last…decade? Longer?
One theory of why it might have been this way was a backlash against Liverpool’s dominance in the 70′s and 80′s. These refs grew up on that and maybe they resent them? Also Heysel and Hillsborough are in the mix perhaps? The Continental ban? Dunno. You have any other ideas? I’m imagining it? Oh, no I’m not. It’s there. Particularly when contrasted with Chelsea the last 6 or 7 years.
Oh, and Miereles was sorely missed today. Difference maker, all by himself.